Berry lip and smudged eyeliner, anyone?
I know this kind of makeup isn't for everyone, but I have always had a secret love for "gothic" (I absolutely hate using this word for this, but it's the only one I can think of that everyone would get) type looks.
The Craft is actually my favorite movie of all time, and Nancy's character is one of my favorites. Maybe she kinda started my love for dark, smokey eyes. Because I damn sure prefer smudged/dark eye looks over lighter, simpler ones. *Shrugs* who knows.